Affiliate disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. If you click one and make a purchase, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We only recommend tools based on independent, research-grounded comparisons.
Toast is one of the most recognized names in restaurant technology. Its captured positioning describes a platform that combines hardware, software, and payment processing, serving restaurant types from quick service and fine dining to food trucks, hotels, catering, and drive-throughs. It covers a broad surface area — point of sale, online ordering, kitchen display systems, self-ordering kiosks, delivery integrations (Grubhub, Uber Eats, DoorDash), payroll, team management, guest CRM, gift cards, email marketing, inventory management, xtraCHEF cost analytics, capital loans, and more. Pricing starts at $0/month on the Starter Kit plan, with the Point of Sale plan at $69/month billed monthly.
That said, Toast isn’t the right fit for everyone. Maybe the pricing model doesn’t suit your operation, or you want a different hardware setup, or you’re primarily looking for online ordering tools rather than a full POS stack. The four alternatives below are all grounded in captured data — here’s what each one actually offers.
A note on reviews: We don’t have third-party review data for any of the tools in this guide, so you won’t find user ratings or complaint patterns here. We’d suggest cross-referencing with review sites like G2 or Capterra directly before making a final call.
The Alternatives at a Glance
| Tool | Entry Price | Top Published Plan | Quote Required? |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toast | $0/month | $69/month | No (custom quotes available) |
| Square for Restaurants | $0/month | $149/month | No |
| Lightspeed Restaurant | $69/month | $399/month (Enterprise: quote) | For Enterprise only |
| UpMenu | $49/month | $169/month | No |
Square for Restaurants
Square positions its restaurant POS as “all-in-one software to manage your restaurant efficiently,” with a free entry tier. The Locations plan (which is the clearest apples-to-apples pricing signal in the captured data) runs $0/month on the Free tier, $49/month on Plus, and $149/month on Premium, all billed monthly. Add-ons include a Kitchen Display System app ($30/device on Plus, $20/device on Premium), a Kiosk app ($50/device on Plus, $30/device on Premium), and restaurant inventory via Square Restaurant Inventory by MarketMan at $99/month on both Plus and Premium.
Captured feature items cover quick service, full service, bars & breweries, food trucks, and coffee shops. Functional areas include taking payments, managing orders, scheduling and paying your team, managing cash flow, tracking inventory, tracking performance, and adding revenue streams. Physical and eGift cards, Afterpay, and Bitcoin payments are also listed. Hardware options include a reader for contactless and chip, a reader for magstripe, and a broader hardware catalog.
Processing rates are listed in the captured data but the specific percentages weren’t captured, so check Square’s pricing page directly for current figures.
Consider Square if… you want a $0 entry point with the option to scale up to paid tiers as your operation grows, or you run a quick-service, bar, food truck, or coffee shop format and want a plan with transparent per-location pricing and optional hardware add-ons.
Lightspeed Restaurant
Lightspeed describes itself as “a flexible, customizable restaurant point of sale, payments and restaurant management platform with industry-leading insights.” It covers restaurant formats including bar, brewery, cafe, fine dining, full service, hotel, and quick service.
Plans run $69/month (Starter), $189/month (Essential), and $399/month (Premium), all billed monthly. An Enterprise tier is available but requires a custom quote from their sales team.
The captured feature set spans Point of Sale, Inventory Management, Kitchen Display System, Tableside POS, Online Ordering, QR Code Ordering, Tableside Ordering, Reservations, Customer Facing Display, Payroll & Workforce Management, Delivery, Accounting, Payment Processing, Advanced Marketing, and several items flagged as new in the platform: Lightspeed AI, Tasks, Tempo, Kitchen Display System (new), and Capital. There are also features listed as Lightspeed Insights, Lightspeed Pulse, Advanced Insights, and Benchmarks & Trends — the data names these but doesn’t detail their mechanics, so we’d suggest a demo to see exactly what they cover.
The platform also notes support for multiple locations and indicates it powers businesses in over 100 countries.
Consider Lightspeed if… you operate a more complex format — fine dining, hotel restaurant, or a multi-location group — and want a platform with a published tiered structure, an Enterprise path for custom needs, and a feature set that includes items like Reservations, Workforce & Payroll, and Advanced Insights listed natively in the platform catalog.
UpMenu
UpMenu positions itself as “everything your restaurant needs to succeed online,” which gives you an honest signal about where its focus sits — it leans into the digital and online ordering side of the restaurant stack rather than leading with in-restaurant POS hardware.
Plans are $49/month (Basic), $89/month (Standard), and $169/month (Premium), all billed monthly.
The feature catalog includes a Restaurant POS, Food Ordering System, Website Builder with 40+ website templates, a Mobile App (branded iOS and Android), QR Code Menu, Reservation System, Tableside Ordering, Restaurant Delivery Software, Delivery Dispatcher, Order Aggregation, Restaurant Order Management Software, Loyalty Program, Marketing Tools, Catering Software, Restaurant CRM, and a Free Setup Service. Ecommerce for restaurants and contactless ordering are also listed.
The breadth of the digital-facing features — branded mobile app, website builder, delivery dispatcher, order aggregation, loyalty program, CRM — makes UpMenu a notably different emphasis from Toast’s hardware-forward stack.
Consider UpMenu if… your priority is building out your restaurant’s digital presence and online ordering channels (website, branded app, delivery management, loyalty program) and you want transparent, lower-entry pricing to do it. It’s also worth a look if catering software or order aggregation is on your wishlist and you’d rather start from $49/month than navigate a hardware-heavy POS selection process.
Quick Comparison: How These Tools Differ
All four platforms list POS, online ordering, and some form of delivery or ordering management in their captured features. Where they diverge in the captured data:
- Toast is the only one with explicitly captured delivery marketplace integrations (Grubhub, Uber Eats, DoorDash named directly), capital loans, xtraCHEF cost analytics, and a payroll suite — along with the broadest captured list of restaurant format types.
- Square is the only one with a genuine $0/month starting plan for restaurants alongside captured Afterpay and Bitcoin payment options.
- Lightspeed is the only one with a published Enterprise tier (quote-based) and has items like Benchmarks & Trends, Lightspeed AI, and Tempo listed in its current feature catalog.
- UpMenu is the only one to list a Delivery Dispatcher, Order Aggregation, 40+ website templates, and a Free Setup Service as captured features — and it leads with an online-first positioning.
Every pricing figure above is sourced directly from the captured fact sheet. Before you commit, verify current rates directly with each vendor — pricing pages update frequently and processing rates weren’t fully captured for Square.